We’re mostly on board with this proposal, with only a few comments.
We would suggest considering letting Entropy still manage things as whole but bringing in SPs as advisors with lesser roles to help continue to manage the allocations that were started with the original TMC as well as the risk monitoring that was already mentioned. We don’t think Entropy would do a bad job, but the team did suggest three members to handle this as part of the TMC in the first place, while acknowledging that they would fit better on the GMC side and as far as we’re aware there hasn’t been any large changes there. As Matt mentioned during the most recent Open Proposals call, Entropy did not yet have anyone on the team that was specialized in handling allocations and while we are confident they’ll pick someone talented, that person could probably use some outside help as well.
We don’t quite understand this answer in the context that it was replying to, is the quarterly reporting for all the initiatives? The monthly reporting done on STEP was mentioned specifically, which already has a dashboard built by Steakhouse. Entropy may rebuild this in a better way or with a different frontend but we don’t see why that would mean reducing the reporting from monthly to quarterly. As I’m sure most people who have had jobs where they built dashboards are aware, there are a lot of users who will never go look at a dashboard but do still expect information synthesized for them, and we’re not sure that changes across domains or with more training. We can see how quarterly might fit better for the TMC/GMC parts, but we don’t see much of a reason why that couldn’t also be monthly too.
Lastly, we want to note that as mentioned during the most recent treasury management call, this proposal assumes Entropy continues to function in its current capacity for the DAO going forward. We think that’s a reasonable assumption but would not want this to go beyond a temp check until the other proposal is figured out or this one is changed such that another entity could step into Entropy’s role.