[DIP v1.5] Delegate Incentive Program Results (December 2024)

Title: Dispute

Larva

Thanks for your clarification! I can’t find the meeting histroy, so just let it go.

What counts as presence is that among the 18 proposals you mentioned, I must have feedback in December, and feedback before that does not count, right? Can you tell me how these 18 presence-related proposals came about? I usually commented on some proposals very early, most delegates commented in December, but I commented on the proposals when they came out at the end of November. How do delegates know which month they should be involved?

The proposal [RFC]: Fund Completion of CEX-> DEX Incentive Research was posted in November and the 90% feedback of delegates posted in November too, but it was counted as presence in December. Shouldn’t it be that only proposals posted in December should count as presence in December?

And I really think my feedback of [NON-CONSTITUTIONAL] Proposal for Maintenance and Continuous Enhancement of ArbitrumHub to Meet the Evolving Needs of the Arbitrum Ecosystem and DAO should not be given 0 score. Because it’s not the only comment I sent in this proposal. I asked the proposer many questions before and even got resonated with other delegates. So I think this sentence is a normal interaction and a polite summary after the long communication with a proposer. I think it could be judged as invalid, but it is unfair to give me 0 points.