December 2024
//////////////////////////
Snapshot
[1] Arbitrum D.A.O. Domain Allocator Offerings) Grant Program - Season 3
Vote: Renew with 5 domains
Rationale:
We have voted to renew the grant program for Season 3, expanding to five domains by adding Orbit. In previous seasons, the program demonstrated acceptable results; for instance, Season 1 achieved a completion rate of 73%. Therefore, we believe it is prudent to continue into Season 3.
Orbit is essential to the Arbitrum ecosystem as it enables developers to launch customizable Layer 2 and Layer 3 chains, enhancing scalability and interoperability within the network. Consequently, we support the inclusion of five domains in the upcoming season.
[2] ARDC (V2) Risk Election
Vote: 100% for Nethermind
Rationale:
Having a prior role in the STEP Committee that oversaw the deployment of $35M in stablecoin investments, Nethermind’s skills in managing financial risks was clearly demonstrated. The expertise in risk assessment and coming up with solutions in tokenomics in their works with dYdX and Puffer Finance also further supports this. Their proposal for the Incentive Programme Allocation Framework, unlike other candidates, includes defining quantitative milestones which is something we agree with as a structured approach that should be implemented to ensure that incentives are effective.
While other candidates bring great value, we believe either their scopes are too narrow and too focused, for example, on governance attack vectors. It may also be the case that they lacked the financial modelling experience that Nethermind offers. Overall, from their past impact on the DAO, we think they should be able to align to ArbitrumDAO’s goals.
[3] ARDC (V2) Supervisory Council Election
Vote: 100% on Frisson (Comm Role)
Rationale:
Frisson has demonstrated significant engagement in Arbitrum’s governance, actively participating in discussions and proposals. Given this active involvement and commitment to the Arbitrum ecosystem, Frisson is well-suited for a communication role within the community.
[4] [NON-CONSTITUTIONAL] Arbitrum Onboarding V2: A Governance Bootcamp
Vote: For
Rationale:
We support the Governance Bootcamp proposal, as it offers a structured pathway for newcomers to effectively engage in Arbitrum’s governance.
Investing in comprehensive programs like this, despite their complexity and time requirements, is essential for the sustainable growth of our governance community.
A clear and well-defined onboarding process will streamline the integration of new participants, enhancing their contributions and fostering a more inclusive ecosystem.
[5] ARDC (V2) Security Election
Vote: 50% for OpenZeppelin, 50% for Trail of Bits
Rationale:
We have allocated our votes equally between OpenZeppelin and Trail of Bits, recognizing both as top-tier security firms in the DeFi space. OpenZeppelin is renowned for its comprehensive security audits and widely-used smart contract libraries, contributing significantly to blockchain security. Trail of Bits has a strong reputation for high-end security research, securing some of the world’s most targeted organizations and products. Their track records make them ideal candidates to enhance the security and integrity of the Arbitrum ecosystem.
[6] ARDC (V2) Research Election
Vote: 40% for The Block, 40% for Blockworks Research, and 20% for Llama Research.
Rationale:
In the ARDC (V2) Research Election, we have allocated our votes as follows: 40% to The Block, 40% to Blockworks Research, and 20% to Llama Research. These weightings reflect our recognition of each firm’s expertise and contributions to the Arbitrum ecosystem.
//////////////////////////
Tally
[1] Arbitrum Hackathon Builder Continuation
Vote: For
Rationale:
This project would allow for projects with high potential to get the resources and funding they need. With mentorship and the right support, it would help create long-term value for the Arbitrum ecosystem. The phases defined help ensure that there is market demand and strong business cases to allow for resources to be allocated to projects that have the highest potential.
This can fast track not just the development of projects but also the growth in the ecosystem. Hackathons are already a great way of gathering a pool of talented individuals with great ideas and helping them with connections and giving the right support should allow these projects to continue on prospering and lead to significant developments.
However, we think that clear milestones should be set for these teams to ensure accountability. There should be some sort of method to measure progress to make sure the teams are moving forward and towards a goal they have. This could be brought up by the RnDao committee after assessment of the teams. Nevertheless, a great initiative.
[2] Treasury Management V1.2
Vote: For
Rationale:
We are voting FOR on Tally. This proposal addresses the issue of underutilised treasury assets and adds an extra layer of security against market volatility by creating a stablecoin reserve and deploying ETH holdings into productive strategies.
However, in future iterations, we believe committee members should be elected with active participation from the DAO. This should allow for more transparency and ensure that the members elected are those that the majority of the DAO truly agrees on. That being said, having compensation being tied to milestones achieved is a step in the right direction, as it promotes accountability and ensures that the appointed members are incentivised to deliver measurable outcomes.
Establishing two management tracks creates a structured approach to optimising resource allocation. The treasury management track should address the immediate need to reduce volatility risks and make sure service providers are paid reliably. The growth track would allow for a forward-looking perspective through building partnerships and investing in ETH-backed strategies.
Ultimately, This is a good first step and a solid foundation for improving the DAO’s financial management and operational efficiency. Improvements should be analysed and addressed in the next iteration.