Transfer 1,800 ETH from the Treasury to the Arbitrum Developer Guild & ATMC’s ETH Treasury Strategies

Non-Constitutional

Edits made on October 26th, 2026

  • Increased the total transfer from 1,700 ETH to 1,800 ETH to include ETH accrued in the treasury since the offchain vote, and updated the amount owed to the ADG to reflect PGA revenue as of October 26th, 2026

Edits made on October 13th, 2026

  • Included the consolidation of PGA fees accrued to the ADG
  • Changed the destination address for funds owed to the ADG to the official ADG address (0x6A075E9a02eef6978DD66cB63DE430a8c0C419E9)

Summary

  • Entropy proposes transferring 1,800 ETH accrued from Sequencer, Timeboost, and PGA revenue from the DAO’s treasury to the Arbitrum Developer Guild & the TM Portfolio

  • In line with the passed proposals to adopt Timeboost and adopt Priority Gas Auctions (PGA), 3% of ETH revenue derived through the transaction ordering mechanisms is to be deposited with the Arbitrum Developer Guild (ADG)

  • Timeboost LTD revenue is ~2,750 ETH. No ETH related to Timeboost has been transferred to the ADG previously; the treasury now holds ~83 ETH that is owed to the guild. Total Timeboost fees collected can be verified here

  • PGA LTD revenue is ~126 ETH. No ETH related to PGA has been transferred to the ADG previously; the treasury now holds ~4 ETH that is owed to the guild as of October 26th, 2026. Total PGA fees collected can be verified here (note that PGA fees will continue to accrue while this proposal is on the forum)

  • In tandem, this proposal would move ~1,700 ETH to the TM portfolio, helping reinitiate the covered call strategy, which has historically been a strong driver of returns

  • The exact amounts to be moved are as follows: 86.27 ETH to the ADG (82.5 ETH related to Timeboost & 3.77 ETH related to PGA) and 1,713.73 ETH to the TM portfolio (1,333.31 ETH and 380.42 WETH)

  • ETH’s share in the TM portfolio is ~37%, and would increase to ~39% if this proposal were to pass, assuming an ETH price of $2,700

  • The ATMC has generated almost 600 ETH to date by activating idle ETH from the treasury, with the blended 30D MA APY fluctuating roughly between 2-7%, mostly driven by whether or not the covered call strategy is active

  • Using the benchmark rate as the opportunity cost, the yearly cost of the 1.7K idle ETH in the treasury is roughly $105K

Motivation / Rationale

ETH Owed to the Arbitrum Developer Guild

In line with the passed proposals to activate Timeboost and PGA, 3% of revenue generated by the transaction ordering mechanisms is to be allocated to the Arbitrum Developer Guild. This allocation isn’t automatic. All Timeboost- and PGA-related income has been streamed directly to the DAO’s treasury. With Timeboost having been replaced by PGA, no more revenue will derive from Timeboost, and we consider this to be a good time to transfer the ETH owed to the ADG.

In practice, this would take place by withdrawing ETH equivalent to the amount owed to the ADG from the treasury into the official ADG address (0x6A075E9a02eef6978DD66cB63DE430a8c0C419E9), from where funds are allocated in line with the ADG’s mandate. Timeboost and PGA have produced 2,750.42 ETH and 125.65 ETH in LTD revenue, respectively, so the amount to be moved over to the ADG totals 86.27 ETH.

Given the treasury has now accumulated around 1.8K ETH, we’re proposing to combine the withdrawal to the ADG with upsizing the TM portfolio’s ETH holdings to reduce the number of standalone proposals that have to be voted on as well as minimize the opportunity cost related to holding idle ETH in the treasury.

Opportunity Cost

At present, around 1,800 ETH sits idle in the treasury, generating no yield and contributing minimally to the growth of the ecosystem. Allocating this ETH, net of ETH owed to the ADG, to yield-generating strategies is in line with treasury management best practices. Assuming a prospective allocation of 1,700 ETH and a conservative ETH-denominated yield of ~2.3% in line with the current benchmark rate, the DAO is foregoing approximately 39 ETH annually.

From a treasury management perspective, maintaining a passive ETH position without a corresponding yield strategy is suboptimal, especially when there exists a variety of deployments that would be appropriate to allocate it to, including but not limited to staking, covered calls, and supplying to lending markets.

Covered calls are currently the best yield-generating strategy on ETH available to the portfolio at size without exposure to additional risks such as collateral depeg, liquidation, negative carry, and exit liquidity. However, given the IPS’ long-term portfolio composition target of 30% ETH, and the fact that ETH may be called away if the covered call strategy expires ITM, we’d prefer the portfolio to hold more ETH to restart the strategy responsibly.

ETH currently makes up ~37% of the total portfolio, so there is still room for rebalancing before the 30% target is reached. However, a 30% decrease in the price of ETH (ETH at ~$1,750) would already shrink the asset class’ share below the long-term target. As such, we’re looking to increase ETH as a % of the portfolio before reinstating the covered call strategy.

Although working as a lever to reinstate the covered call strategy is a notable benefit of increasing the TM portfolio’s ETH allocation, this doesn’t rule out the possibility of deploying the new ETH across a variety of low-risk strategies. The new ETH tranche doesn’t necessarily mirror the existing treasury strategy deployments. Entropy will proactively engage with protocols providing services that align with the ATMC’s strategic goals and growth of the Arbitrum ecosystem.

In line with the established ATMC structure, the elected OAT body will maintain full ability to approve or deny allocation decisions. The ~1,700 ETH will be sent to and custodied by the Arbitrum Foundation. Rebalancing needs will be examined as part of our normal treasury management reporting cadence, considering liquidity constraints, yield conditions, or shifts in ecosystem needs. The DAO maintains the ability to direct or wind down this activity at any time through its standard governance process.

Target Timeline

  1. Forum Period: October 8th - October 15th

  2. Offchain Voting Period: October 15th - October 22nd

  3. Onchain Voting Period: October 29th - November 12th

  4. In case the proposal passes the onchain phase, move ETH owed to the ADG into 0x6A075E9a02eef6978DD66cB63DE430a8c0C419E9, and transfer the remainder to the TM portfolio

1 Like

Thank you for setting out both the proposed ADG payment and the plan for deploying idle ETH. The 82.51 ETH figure is consistent with 3% of the stated 2,750.42 ETH in Timeboost revenue, and the opportunity-cost estimate is broadly consistent with 1,600 ETH at a 2.3% benchmark. Evaluating how idle treasury assets can be used productively is worthwhile, while expected returns should remain distinct from the risks involved.

A few details would help delegates assess the proposal: @Entropy

  1. Could you provide a reconciliation of the 2,750.42 ETH in revenue and the 82.51 ETH payment, including the period covered and source data? Does the 3% allocation apply only to Timeboost proceeds, or to PGA revenue as well?
  2. Before the transfer, can the DAO see the proposed mandate and limits for the new ETH allocation—including caps by protocol, counterparty and strategy, plus the OAT’s approval and emergency-withdrawal process?
  3. For the reported 600 ETH generated and 2–7% 30-day APY range, could you share a dated breakdown of realized and unrealized returns, fees, the benchmark definition, and comparable measurement periods?
  4. For covered calls, what limits and stress scenarios will govern option size, ETH called away, downside exposure and time to unwind? How will custody controls and OAT allocation decisions be reported?
  5. Could the ADG payment and TM Portfolio allocation be voted on separately, or specified as distinct executable actions, so delegates can express a different view on each?

These clarifications would help distinguish the proposed ADG payment from the separate decision to authorize additional treasury deployment.

4 Likes

@Arb_Junior Thank you for the questions. You can find answers to all of them on arbdata.com as well as in the DAO’s Investment Policy Statement, which can be found here. We don’t see a need to split the vote, but we’re open to doing so if delegates express support for it in this thread.

1 Like

Thanks for pointing to arbdata.com and the DAO Investment Policy Statement. Could you link the specific sections that address these questions in the proposal thread? That would make it easier for delegates to find and assess the information relevant to this decision.

On the vote structure, separating the ADG payment from the portfolio allocation would let delegates express different preferences on each. If delegates support that distinction, it would be helpful to hear their views here.

I support paying the Developer Guild’s accrued allocation and deploying idle ETH through the existing treasury management framework.

I expect transparent reporting of net returns, and ETH sold through covered calls.

cp0x voted Against.

We support paying the Arbitrum Developer Guild its share of Timeboost and PGA revenue. Based on the stated figures, 3% of the combined 2,750.42 ETH in Timeboost revenue and 87 ETH in PGA revenue is approximately 85.1 ETH, and the payment follows the allocation set out in the Timeboost and PGA AIPs. Our vote is against the allocation of 1,614.9 ETH to the TM portfolio, which in its current form does not give delegates enough clarity to support it.

A central argument for the allocation is that additional ETH would help restart the covered call strategy. The March proposal put the portfolio’s ETH weight at 39.7% and projected around 47% after the 6,000 ETH transfer, at an assumed price of $2,200. This proposal puts the weight at about 37% with an assumed price of $2,700. These percentages alone do not establish whether the portfolio’s ETH holdings have declined. The proposal does not reconcile the current allocation with the position projected in March or explain the contributions of portfolio flows, rebalancing and valuation changes. It also explains the current reluctance to restart covered calls, but does not provide a dated account of when and why the strategy was paused or whether previous options resulted in ETH being called away.

The March proposal included sector yields against benchmarks and linked to a detailed allocation breakdown, while this one gives a cumulative figure of almost 600 ETH and a roughly 2–7% range for the 30-day moving-average annualized yield. Questions about this in the thread were answered with a reference to arbdata.com and the IPS. The portfolio overview does not clearly identify whether the covered call strategy is currently active and notes that certain assets temporarily held offchain are excluded. The proposal does not say where the covered calls are executed or how the new tranche would be split between covered calls and other strategies.

Bundling the guild payment with the portfolio allocation also means that delegates cannot express separate preferences on the guild payment and the portfolio allocation through this vote. We would support a version that votes on the two separately, reconciles the portfolio’s ETH position with the March projection, and sets out how the new tranche would be deployed.

Voting FOR, same as the 6,000 ETH vote some time ago. Idle ETH should be working, and the ATMC has been making money for the DAO so I’m happy to give them more. The Guild part we already agreed on.

Entropy’s October 8 treasury-transfer proposal, revised October 13, reports 2,750.42 ETH in lifetime Timeboost proceeds and approximately 87 ETH in lifetime PGA proceeds. Applying the approved 3% allocation produces approximately 82.51 ETH and 2.61 ETH, respectively, consistent with the proposal’s rounded 85.1 ETH ADG allocation.

The approximately 87 ETH figure is a governance-proposal-reported amount. I have not independently reconciled it to the underlying PGA collection transactions. Likewise, the proposed ADG allocation should not be described as a completed transfer before execution evidence exists.

Merlyn Labs is voting FOR this proposal. The guild payment is already agreed upon and idle ETH should be earning.

The following reflects the views of GMX’s Governance Committee, and is based on the combined research, evaluation, consensus, and ideation of various committee members.

We are generally in favour of this proposal and support the 85.1 ETH payment to the ADG. In reference to the remaining ETH for the TM allocation, we would have preferred a spread of ETH strategies rather than a primary focus on covered calls. As the July-Aug report shows, ETH’s price rally in August led to it being called away below market, which shows the concentration and price risk of relying on one strategy.

Nevertheless, we’re supportive given the ATMC’s track record and the OAT’s oversight.

We support this transfer based on the prior commitment to the Arbitrum Developer Guild and on putting idle ETH into yield-generating strategies. The Guild’s 85.1 ETH is the unpaid 3% of Timeboost and PGA revenue, an allocation the DAO already approved. The remaining 1,614.9 ETH sits in the treasury earning nothing. Moving it into the treasury portfolio lets that capital work, including a restart of covered calls, which need a larger ETH buffer so ETH sold through the strategy does not push the portfolio through its 30% target.

Entropy is acknowledging its COI as a member of the ATMC. We will be voting FOR as we believe its important for the DAO to begin deploying these idle funds to earn yield and complete the payment owed to the ADG.

Voting FOR. ETH sitting idle in the treasury is just leaving money on the table, and the ATMC has shown they can put it to work, so lfg.

Voted FOR.
In favor of moving the assets into the TM portfolio - personally not convinced a covered call is the best strategy in this market as we risk giving up significant upside in exchange for minimum yield.

Cornell Blockchain is voting FOR this proposal to put the idle ETH to work.

The following reflects the views of L2BEAT’s governance team, composed of @krst and @Manugotsuka, and is based on their combined research, fact-checking, and discussion.

We voted FOR.

We do not have concerns with the 85.1 ETH allocated to the Arbitrum Developer Guild, as this corresponds to revenue the DAO has already approved.

For the remaining 1,614.9 ETH, we think it makes sense to keep putting idle ETH to work instead of leaving it sitting in the treasury. Looking back at the previous 6,000 ETH allocation earlier this year, the June ATMC update shows that those funds were deployed into ether.fi, while the portfolio continued using ETH across strategies such as covered calls.

There is also enough history now to see how some of those positions evolved. In August, the ATMC reported that covered calls on 6.75K ETH expired in the money, resulting in roughly $15.2M in stablecoins for the DAO.

During a governance call, we asked how the new 1,614.9 ETH would be used. The team clarified that the ETH will be kept as ETH and will allow the ATMC to restart the covered call strategy without pushing the portfolio below its 30% minimum ETH benchmark. That gives us a much clearer picture of why the additional ETH is needed.

We also appreciate the acknowledgment that future proposals like this should explain the intended strategy more clearly from the start. With that clarification, we support the transfer.

MUX is in favor of this transfer, given the existing commitment to the Arbitrum Developer Guild and the plan to put otherwise idle ETH to work through yield-generating strategies.

Reverie is voting FOR this proposal for two reasons. (i) The 85.1 ETH owed to the ADG has already been approved under timeboost and PGA, so we don’t see any reason to oppose it. (ii) We generally think it’s better for the remaining ~1,615 ETH to be deployed into yield-generating strategies rather than sitting idle in the treasury, particularly given the ATMC’s track record of generating returns on its existing ETH holdings.

I support this proposal, consistent with my temperature-check position.

Paying the Developer Guild’s accrued allocation and deploying idle ETH through the existing treasury framework are reasonable steps.

I continue to expect transparent reporting of net returns and ETH sold through covered calls, so delegates can assess the income earned alongside any forgone upside.

Voting FOR, my stance remains the same. Happy to see another 100 ETH of revenue came in since the temp check.