I’ll be voting “For” once this goes to Snapshot. I think if I was asked this on day 1 of Arbitrum delegation I probably would not have seen much value. However, over the last year+ it’s been become clearer to me the value of this. Even thought I think most delegates are subconsciously making decisions with these ideas in mind, having the formal blueprint should be helpful. There isn’t really a downside here, so I see no reason not to move forward with this.
I’m not really the type of person whose good at mission statement type things, so I’ll sort of leave feedback to “I think it sounds good!”. But some general thoughts:
I agree with others about making this unique to Arbitrum. With really anything, having a really generic purpose sort of leads itself to being low impact.
I also appreciate the continued focus on Ethereum. I think this an important ideology to maintain.
Following changes made to this proposal on October 30, several delegates contacted us and provided further feedback. Upon additional conversations, it’s clear that more discourse and potential iteration are needed before moving to Snapshot. Consequently, we will be pushing voting for 1 to 2 weeks.
;Hi, Drafting a Mission, Vision and Purpose is difficult. Based on the comments in the forum there are many different opinions. Also there are informal meetings in the background, making the drafting harder still.
Attached is a SimScore report.
SimScore uses methods that underpin data science technology: Centroid to determine clusters within the data. Similarity Score determine the similarity of each answer to the central theme…The score is 0-100%, higher scores being most similar. This established a priority list.
Entropy can choose which ideas they will incorporate into the proposals Green) and comment on the changes they intend to make. They can also choose ideas they will not incorporate (Red)
This should make everything transparent.
I hope this method moves things along…as the Discourse open discussion along with informal meetings seems to be cumbersome.
Based on SImScorr’s unbiased aggregation, the above statement is #1 priority, it should be the basis for improvements. The mvp needs to tell a story or narrative
The current proposal update by Entropy does not refer to this #1 statement by Clifton. For more clarity look at simscore report above.
